New Scientist Responds
I just received the following comment from Grahm Lawton, features editor for the New Scientist magazine. "Graham Lawton, features editor, New Scientist said... Disclaimer: This comment is from the features editor at New Scientist. John, don't shoot the messenger... Boltzmann brains are a genuine problem in cosmology. Serious cosmologists take them seriously. We report on what they're thinking, in an honest and balanced way. What's the problem? We don't make this stuff up, you know - if you don't believe me, plug " Bolzmann brains" into Google scholar. If you don't approve of the fact that people are working on this problem (spending your tax dollars) that is your prerogative, but have a go at them, not us!" I think Grahm makes a reasonable point. If, in fact, the Boltzmann Brains 'problem' is treated seriously by serious scientists then I grant it is worthy of a mention in a science magazine. That said, I don't think 'New S